Is Gold Overstaying Its Welcome?

Date Written: 21st July, 2025

Introduction

Gold’s role as a universal safe haven is once again being tested. The yellow metal is struggling to gain traction amid mixed macroeconomic signals. Earlier this year, the yellow metal sharply extended its rally from $2,600/oz to $3,500/oz amid growing expectations of rate cuts from the FED, central bank intervention, renewed conflict in the Middle East and strong inflow into GLD ETFs. However, as we move into Q3, gold continues to trade within a two-month range of $3,500/oz and $2,850/oz, raising concerns that gold may now be overvalued. As investors await key economic data, gold’s relaxation has left investors no choice but to seek alternatives such as silver and platinum, both currently outperforming the traditional safe haven asset. As a result, we have conflicting forces simultaneously inducing a steady support and resistance for gold.

Technical View: Gold Running Out of Steam?

From a technical perspective the outlook for gold is fundamentally range bound, and traders keep lifting offers at the $3,280-$3,300 handles, but haven't made a strong break above $3,500. The RSI indicates that we are nearing overbought levels, despite increased inflows into gold ETFs. This suggests short term exhaustion with the bullish trend. Offers keep getting hit at the top of the range, but a lack of follow-through implies the smart money has already rotated out.

Silver and Platinum: The Quiet Rotation

Both silver and platinum are increasing in popularity as inflation hedges and industrial demand plays. The metals are increasingly catching bids and are outperforming gold YTD. This may be a structural shift, as investors look for relative value, and right now gold's stretched multiple is beginning to look rich.

(Silver, Platinum Year-To-Date Graph; TradingView 2025)

Powell, Politics, & Inflation Pressures

Undoubtedly, one of the most important factors offering resistance for gold are the FED’s outlook on inflation. Now, we know that Powell has been under heavy scrutiny from the likes of Donald Trump with his approach in achieving the dual mandate; however, from my perspective, Powell’s ‘Higher for Longer’ approach reflects his prudent nature to not cut prematurely and to avoid another inflation spiral. Let's have a look at inflation:

(U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics via FRED, 2025)

At 2.67%, headline inflation is still 0.67% above the FED’s 2% target, with core inflation still proving a significant problem for the FED due to wage growth, increasing the business costs which are later passed on to consumers. Therefore, cutting rates now could reignite demand by boosting business and consumer spending, increasing the demand for goods and services, and may risk initiating another wave of inflation.

DXY, Real Yields & Smart Money

In short, the surrounding environment for commodities remains unclear. The dollar index (DXY) has been range-trading near key support at 90. Positioning is extremely net-short, so a bounce is not out of the question. If the dollar does get off of this level, gold will face even further headwinds. 

(DXY Year-To-Date Index Graph; TradingView, 2025)

Additionally, real yields are facing more stability, and since the Fed has no compelling reason to cut, the cost of carrying asset classes (such as gold which does not yield) is quite high. Treasury volumes picked up as well - the FICC cleared a record $11.8 trillion in U.S. Treasuries in June, indicating a sharp demand for duration.

(US10Y, US20Y Year-To-Date Graph; TradingView, 2025)

What About FX?

This indicates smart money is defensively positioning - not necessarily risk-off but definitely recalibrating for rate stability. Goldman Sachs continues to be constructive on risk assets and considers gold to be part of the portfolio hedge, but we disagree on the timing. We believe they are underestimating the risk of over-positioning (in gold) at these higher levels.

The difference primarily comes down to this: Goldman views gold as a hedge; we view it as a crowded trade. When everyone is long a hedge, who is left to buy it when the volatility hits?

The credit markets depict a similar story. IG spreads are hovering around historical tights, which suggests complacency. New issuance is being bought with almost no concession, but duration risk is badly underappreciated. If inflation ticks up again or the Fed flexes its hawkish posture again, both gold and bonds could be sold off together.

So, Is Gold Overstaying Its welcome?

It depends on your timeframe. In the short term, yes – it is losing momentum, offers are getting filled, but no conviction can be derived from that. The tighter the range, the bigger the warning. However, structurally, gold still has a part to play if inflation surprises or if the Fed pivots too late. Just don't chase it. Be tactical and be conscious of the most important zones: $3,280 as the mental soft floor, $3,500 as stiff resistance. If we cleanly break on volume, great, jump on. But we would rather be a bidder in silver and platinum right now than in gold. 

In a market like this, everything depends on timing - and gold is not the only game in town.